Online Survey: Do You Believe That Free Will Exists?

-
See Inside

Vote ‘yes’ or ‘no’ on this seminal question that has perplexed philosophers for millenia


Dec 16, 2014 | |free will

Is Nahmias right and the impression that many of us have is correct: We have the free will to choose one course of action over another. Or are you in the opposite camp?


More In This Article


Philosopher Eddy Nahmias from Georgia State University in support of the idea that free will exists. Our ability to choose left versus right, he thinks, prevails—even when, unbeknownst to all of us, our brains sometimes appear to be grinding away behind the scenes immediately before we actually take a step or utter the first word of a sentence.


Some other philosophers and neuroscientists disagree with Nahmias’s interpretation, however. They point to the same studies that suggest unconscious processes drive our every action—and then conclude free will is nothing more than an illusion.


Whether or not free will actually exists has all sorts of moral and legal consequences:


“My brain made me do it, judge.”


This is an age-old debate that dates back to the ancients. It will likely continue for millennia to come. The debaters need not be confined to the ranks of professional philosophers and neuroscientists.


So we’d like to hear what you think. Is Nahmias right and the impression that many of us have is correct: We have the free will to choose one course of action over another. Or are you in the opposite camp? Do you think our brains decide for us without our being conscious of the machinery by which they carry out subliminal decision-making processes?


Help us out and vote yes or no below. Also, if you wish, leave a comment about why you agree or disagree with the idea that our conscious selves still retain control over what we decide.


The survey will remain on our site until January 10, at which time we will post the results.



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

New Heart Drugs More Expensive than Expected

-
Image
Two of the most anticipated new heart drugs to be launched in recent years have been priced well above analyst expectations, fuelling the debate about whether modern medicines cost too much July 27, 2015 | By Ben Hirschler LONDON (Reuters) - Two of the most anticipated new heart drugs to be launched in recent years have been priced well above analyst expectations, fuelling the debate about whether modern medicines cost too much. Praluent (alirocumab) injection, made by Sanofi and Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, and Entresto (sacubitril/valsartan) from Novartis are both treatments that represent significant advances for millions of patients at risk of serious heart problems. But their positioning in the marketplace was always likely to be contentious since they offer more effective alternatives to very cheap, off-patent drugs. The manufacturers have taken an ambitious view on pricing, arguing that the clear medical benefits of their products and their ability to keep patients out of ...
Read more

The Physics of Baseball: How Far Can You Throw?

-
Image
A sports science activity by Science Buddies By | | What is one trick to throwing a ball farther? Learn a little about physics--and how those baseball outfielders can make such impressive plays--with this fastmoving activity!  Key concepts MotionResistance Introduction Background When air resistance is very low, a projectile moves in the shape of a parabola—a type of mathematical curve. (You can do an Internet search for "parabola" to see what one looks like.) The path the ball follows (called its trajectory) will determine how far it goes before it hits the ground. Adjusting the ball’s initial angle and keeping its initial speed constant is one way to find out the best angle to throw a ball as far as possible. In this experiment you will throw a ball as hard as you can while changing the ball's initial angle relative to the ground. What angle do you think will make the ball go the farthest? Materials Sports ball of your choice (baseball, tennis ball, football, ...
Read more

Can the U.S. Jump-Start Offshore Wind Power?

-
The Department of Energy has awarded around a half-million dollars to New York, Maine, Rhode Island and Massachusetts state organizations to cooperate on scaling up the offshore wind industry in the region. Under the leadership of the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA), the group will lay out a collaborative road map by the end of the year on how to build up the new industry. The project largely aims to reduce the cost of offshore wind projects, which has been a barrier to development, and establish a regional supply chain. Industry and state representatives learned about the federal grant at the first-ever offshore wind summit hosted by the White House yesterday. Offshore wind has struggled to take off in the United States. Europe, meanwhile, has more than 80 offshore wind farms with more than 10,000 megawatts of capacity. The White House summit marks a renewed effort to get the industry going in the United States, said various attendees. “There’s a...
Read more